But nothing could spoil this day.
Woodland gouged it out with a 7-iron with enough strength to get the ball to the front of the green, and he could only smile when the 50-foot putt dropped for birdie (photo) and yet another record at Pebble Beach, not to mention a two-shot lead going into the weekend.
"That was just a bonus," Woodland said. "Hit a beautiful drive. I was in the divot, a pretty deep divot. We were a little indecisive what we were going to do. We tried to take a little less club and hit it hard and play out to the safe to the right, and it was nice to knock it in."
His 6-under 65 matched the U.S. Open record at Pebble Beach for the second time in two days, a testament to a course that was only slightly firmer, but still soft enough under a heavy marine layer with so much condensation it felt like a list mist.
Woodland was at 9-under 133, beating by one shot the 36-hole record at Pebble Beach that Tiger Woods set in his record romp in 2000.
The difference: Woods had a six-shot lead in 2000. Woodland's margin was only two shots over Justin Rose, who had a 70. Louis Oosthuizen didn't make a par on the back nine until the final hole in his wild round of 70 and was three shots behind.
And the weekend remains a mystery, with 31 players still under par through 36 holes and a host of major champions chasing Woodland.
Rory McIlroy, who kept it together right when it looked as though his round was getting away from him, felt the course was a little faster and could really speed up on the weekend. He was among 10 players separated by five shots halfway through a U.S. Open that so far has run smoothly.
That list includes two-time defending champion Brooks Koepka (bottom photo), who made two late birdies for another 69 and was five shots behind.
"I feel great. I'm excited. I've got a chance. That's all you can ask for," Koepka said. "I just need to make a few putts. Sometimes the hole just needs to open up. If I can get off to a good start tomorrow, have that feeling where the hole's opening up, it could be a fun round."
The list does not include Woods.
He made a 10-foot birdie putt on No. 11, his second hole of the round, and made nothing else the rest of the day. That birdie was the only putt he made longer than 5 feet, and he closed with back-to-back bogeys for a 72 to finish nine shots behind.
Rose (photo) set the target early and at one point Friday morning had a four-shot lead until he hit a poor wedge shot to a front pin on No. 3, followed by an iron off the tee at the short, uphill fourth that peeled over the edge of the cliff to the right and into an ice plant, forcing him to take a penalty drop that led to a bogey.
But he had few complaints with a super short game that has carried him for two rounds. Rose got up-and-down from the thick collar short of the green at No. 8, and with a lag putt from the bottom of the green at No. 9.
"At this point, there's not a lot to worry about," Rose said. "If you're one ahead, one behind, it's a lot of golf to be played. But it's the perfect spot after two days."
For the second straight day, Pebble Beach was there for the taking, but only for good, smart shots.
McIlroy also made a run at the lead until he made a bogey from the bunker on the 13th and a mess on the par-5 14th. With the ball slightly above his feet for his wedge-shot approach to the elevated green at the long par-5, and knowing that anything left of the pin would go down a slope with gnarly rough, McIlroy left the shot out to the right and watched it roll back off the green and into the fairway.
He dumped the resulting pitch shot into the front bunker and failed to get up-and-down from the sand. The double bogey left him even par for the round and 3 under for the championship.
He answered with a pair of birdies on 15 and 16.
"Those were huge to get me back into the tournament," McIlroy said.
Oosthuizen, the first player to reach the early target set by Rose at 7 under, gave a shot back with a bogey on No. 8, and then another one at No. 10 that started his roller coaster along the inward nine.
A birdie was followed by two bogeys, followed by two birdies and another bogey.
"Seven birdies and six bogeys — I'm not a big fan of bogeys," Oosthuizen said. "But miss these greens, it's so difficult around the greens in the rough. And you can't control the ball. You basically are guessing what it's going to do. And all those loose iron shots, I had tough chips, and end up bogeying probably all of them."
Phil Mickelson revved up the crowd with three birdies in the opening six holes, and six birdies for the round. He still couldn't stop the mistakes, however, and Lefty had to settle for a 69. He was eight shots behind, needing to get a little closer in range to think about a shot at the career Grand Slam.
Even with two soft days, and slightly firmer conditions, no one expects it to be easier the rest of the way.
Graeme McDowell, who won the U.S. Open at Pebble Beach in 2010 at even-par 284, ran off four straight birdies early in his round, threw in a few mistakes and was wincing over every birdie chance that burned the edge of the cup. He had to settle for a 70 and was six behind, but still hopeful.
"Anything can happen on this golf course over the weekend," he said. "You don't have to do anything fancy tomorrow."